Beginning in 1886, rival factions in the Samoan Islands waged a bitter struggle over who would ascend to the throne. At the same time, German, American, and British forces sought to protect—and in some cases expand—their strategic and commercial interests in the region.
Malietoa Laupepa had been crowned King in March 1881, recognized by the German, American, and British consuls. Yet, several Samoan factions refused to accept his rule. They formed a rival government, proclaiming Tuiātua Tupua Tamasese Titimaea as king. A brief civil conflict ensued until a treaty, mediated by U.S. Navy Captain J. H. Gillis, restored Laupepa as king, with Titimaea as vice-king and Mata’afa Iosefa as premier.
Tensions flared again when Laupepa petitioned Queen Victoria for British protection against German interference in Samoan politics. The German consul responded by banishing Laupepa, installing Titimaea on the throne. This move, however, sparked opposition from Iosefa, setting the stage for the First Samoan Civil War.
The conflict quickly drew in international forces. German warships shelled rebel villages, sometimes destroying American-owned property. In response, the United States sent a naval squadron—including the USS Vandalia, USS Trenton, and USS Nipsic—to Apia Harbour to counter three German vessels: SMS Adler, SMS Eber, and SMS Olga. For nearly two years, the opposing fleets faced each other across the harbor in tense standoffs, under the watchful eye of the British corvette HMS Calliope.
On March 15–16, 1889, the standoff ended not with gunfire but with a cyclone, which destroyed all six German and American ships in the harbor. Remarkably, the Calliope managed to escape, surviving the storm. The disaster claimed over 130 lives and may have prompted the three powers to restore Laupepa as king. Yet the First Samoan Civil War continued until 1894.
After nearly a decade of uneasy peace, turmoil returned in 1898 following Laupepa’s death. Iosefo returned from exile and was elected king by a council of Samoan chiefs, backed by local German forces. Meanwhile, the Americans and British supported Laupepa’s son, Malietoa Tanumafili I.
American and British forces landed at Apia, occupying much of the city. When Mata’afa supporters attacked, the Allies fired from warships, forcing the rebels to retreat to Vailele. Several expeditions into the surrounding jungle followed, with combined British, American, and Samoan forces marching along the coast from Apia to Vailele, engaging in multiple skirmishes along the way.
On April 1, 1899, the cruisers USS Philadelphia, HMS Tauranga, HMS Porpoise, and the corvette HMS Royalist landed troops, while the Royalist bombarded the forts guarding Vailele. The landing party, however, was ambushed by over 800 Matafa loyalists, attacking from the left flank and rear. Close-quarters combat erupted, and a Colt machine gun jammed at a critical moment. When Lieutenant Philip Landsdale, who had assumed command after the death of Royal Navy Lieutenant Angel Hope Freeman, attempted to fix it, he was shot in the thigh. Landsdale ordered a retreat, but several troops who remained with him were killed.
Over the following weeks, the Matafaans launched additional attacks against British and American forces, including a significant engagement just south of Vailele. Despite their persistence, these assaults were ultimately repulsed.
The conflict concluded with the Tripartite Convention of 1899, in which Germany, the United States, and Britain agreed that joint rule of Samoa was unworkable. The islands were partitioned:
- The United States received the eastern islands, forming American Samoa,
- Germany gained the western islands, now the independent nation of Samoa,
- Britain took the northern Solomon Islands—Choiseul, Isabel, and Shortland—previously part of Germany.
The Samoan conflicts of the late 19th century illustrate the complex interplay of local rivalries and imperial ambitions, highlighting how global powers often shaped—and were shaped by—regional disputes.
johnmilner.ca 